The Whole
Brevity Thing
music reviews &
cultural commentary
About this Entry
Posted by: elgaberino

Visit elgaberino's Xanga Site

Original: 1/15/2010 10:50 AM
Views: 3932
Comments: 129
eProps: 118

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site

Friday, January 15, 2010

Decade: Best Ten Albums? You Choose. (UPDATE!)

 
    Pick the Best 10 Albums of the Decade

Welcome to The Whole Brevity Thing.

Tag, you're it.

Uh oh. What? That's right, listeners. We're gonna have a little blog fun here. Here's what you do, if you're game. You do listen to music, don't you? Most people do. Think back through your iPod and CD collections over the last ten years. Go ahead then, write down a couple of them. Good. Now the goal is to list ten: ten albums you think were the greatest ten albums of the last ten years.

Just to get yourself thinking: were you thrilled by Radiohead's new sound when Kid A came out? Were you skeptical about Justin Timberlake when he went solo? Did you already know about the Roots before Phrenology, or Jay-Z before the first The Blueprint disc? Did Jack and Meg White totally rock your stereo, or was it Queens of the Stone Age, when they streamed Lullabies to Paralyze in its entirety on MySpace back in 2005? Did watching the movie Garden State turn you on to the Shins in time for Chutes Too Narrow? Did you think American Idiot was the best thing that happened in the last ten years, or the worst... or did you totally forget about it? Is Iron & Wine your volume level, or do you prefer System of a Down? How about it, Franz Ferdinand or The Killers? Would you pick Coldplay over Nickelback, or do you think they're both horrible? How about that crush you had when you first heard Norah Jones's Come Away With Me, or Alicia Keys's Songs in A Minor, or Feist's The Reminder?

See? You've gotta have at least ten albums that shaped your last decade. Maybe just one album for each year; the hard part will be limiting it to just ten! Maybe write a little bit about each of your ten favorite albums, if you want, and tell your readers why you think they're good, or why they're your favorites. Post them to your blog, and I'll recommend your post, and give you some credits. I have a ton. Then I'll feature your list on my blog, and we can all read each others' lists.

Remember, a good song doesn't make a good album. Some albums only have one or two good numbers on them. (And the albums should have been released between January 1, 2000 and December 31, 2009.)

Five years ago The Whole Brevity Thing asked readers what were their favorite albums of all time. The resulting mixture of responses [link] was gratifyingly diverse, though it could have been moreso. Still, It represented one of the strengths of the internet's influence on music: you can like whatever you like without some radio DJ telling you otherwise. That made this decade distinct from all the other decades. Just think, it wasn't that long ago you had a Walkman and iPods didn't exist yet. We've loved so many songs since then!

You're In!

  • Make a list, and share it with us. Post it on your blog, let me know, and I'll post it here.
  • Recommend this post, and other peoples' lists. We'll have a big blog music party.
Let's turn Xanga into a music blog this month, in appreciation of all the great music over the last ten years. Don't forget to recommend this post too, or plug it if you don't mind. I want to get the word out, meet some new bloggers, hear what people think were the greatest music releases so far this century.

I'll bet you already have an album in mind, so start typing that list. Ready. Set.

Go.
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   




UPDATE! A growing group of Xangans have chosen their top ten lists! In February I'll be putting up a post collecting all the results of Xanga's music choices for the decade. Get your list included! Albums selected by multiple people so far include Illinois by Sufjan Stevens, Abattoir Blues/Lyre of Orpheus by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb by U2, Get Behind Me, Satan by the White Stripes, and two Radiohead albums, including the much debated Kid A, which has gotten two votes for best album.


 Posted 1/15/2010 10:50 AM - 3932 Views - 118 eProps - 129 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

129 Comments

browse comments: next › | last »


Visit vanedave's Xanga Site!
This is one hell of a task to complete. I think I might give it a shot. Difficult as it may be.
Posted 1/11/2010 1:24 PM by vanedave Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit elgaberino's Xanga Site!

@vanedave - I would take your list as having some authority. Partially just because you think it's a hard task. I expect a lot of people will just list the ten CD's floating around their car. But maybe that's okay too, you know? If an album isn't floating around someone's car, maybe it isn't one of the best?

Posted 1/11/2010 1:36 PM by elgaberino Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit vanedave's Xanga Site!
Gotta admit, your tags are helping to jog my memory a bit. I almost forgot about Coldplay.
Posted 1/11/2010 1:41 PM by vanedave Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit woodrowwilson's Xanga Site!
if an album is floating around my car, it means i picked it up off the street to use as a coaster. i don't think i've bought more than 5 compact disk recordings this entire decade.
Posted 1/11/2010 2:35 PM by woodrowwilson - recommend - reply

Visit elgaberino's Xanga Site!

@woodrowwilson - Now I am curious about what would be on your list. Don't you burn stuff to play in your car?

Posted 1/11/2010 3:06 PM by elgaberino Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit TheBigShowAtUD's Xanga Site!

this IS hard.  i'll have to sleep on it after i look through my cds.  i know i'll end up leaving out two or three that'll come to me, later.


ryc:  ha, yeah, but he listens to you, and tells people you're right.   

Posted 1/11/2010 3:54 PM by TheBigShowAtUD Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit elgaberino's Xanga Site!

@woodrowwilson - 

@TheBigShowAtUD -  spare a rec, gents? trying to get the word out.

Posted 1/11/2010 5:23 PM by elgaberino Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit curtainsopen's Xanga Site!
this one will take some thought.  give me a day or two.
Posted 1/11/2010 5:50 PM by curtainsopen Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit tenshii_rage's Xanga Site!
Justin Bieber. Obviously.
Posted 1/11/2010 6:59 PM by tenshii_rage Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit trunthepaige's Xanga Site!
I will get back to you to you. I'm a product of my generation. I think in terms of singles on my play list
Posted 1/11/2010 7:00 PM by trunthepaige Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit CallMeQuell's Xanga Site!
Oh boy. This'll take me awhile. But YEAH I wanna do it!

...Shoot. I'm scared of missing something because there were so many albums. Yeeps. Guess I'll go gut Pitchfork. Ha. Sigh.
Posted 1/11/2010 7:00 PM by CallMeQuell Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit trunthepaige's Xanga Site!

@vanedave - 

Dude rec this one. Your readers would love this
Posted 1/11/2010 7:01 PM by trunthepaige Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit iamthebella's Xanga Site!
this will be fun.
Posted 1/11/2010 7:04 PM by iamthebella Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit xXbUbBlEwRaPXx's Xanga Site!
Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster.

That's all I have to say.
Posted 1/11/2010 7:05 PM by xXbUbBlEwRaPXx Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit kkrriiissyy's Xanga Site!
You have a fantastic list. Tomorrow when I have a bit of time to kill I think I'll make a list as well. ♥
Posted 1/11/2010 7:06 PM by kkrriiissyy Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit elgaberino's Xanga Site!

@curtainsopen - Take your time. I plan to try to gather lists even into February. A rec would help too. See what your readers are listening to, etc.

@tenshii_rage - ha, well, that's ONE artist. Tenshii likes Bieber. Duly noted.

@trunthepaige - W00t, it will be great to see the "trun top ten" ...bahahahahaha! I am so clever.

@CallMeQuell - Okay if it makes you feel any better (see my above reply to curtains) you have time, ANNND I am going to be posting my rough top-200 list within a week or two, so that might help jog your memories, etc. And rec this post and pimp it out like crazy. I wanna get a lot of people involved like with the top 5's. After all, we are the rightful elected rulers of Xanga.

Posted 1/11/2010 7:09 PM by elgaberino Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit elgaberino's Xanga Site!

@trunthepaige - I think he did. Good ol' dave.

@iamthebella - YES IT WILL!

@xXbUbBlEwRaPXx - Really? Ten years go by and it's summarized by Gaga? I mean she's not bad, but you MUST have more than that.

@petitenoirtenue - Sweet. Can't wait to see it. But those up there were just suggestions. I haven't finished my actual list yet. Haha.

@CallMeQuell - Oh, you ninja woman, you rec'd while I was typing. Thx.

Posted 1/11/2010 7:12 PM by elgaberino Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit kkrriiissyy's Xanga Site!

@elgaberino - 

In that case, I like your suggestions. ♥
Posted 1/11/2010 7:13 PM by kkrriiissyy Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit skittlesruletheworld's Xanga Site!
I feel that I am deeply disqualified, having never kept up with the music scene in any substantial way, but by gum I'll do it sometime this month. Just because you continue to amaze me by being the best blogger here.
Posted 1/11/2010 7:15 PM by skittlesruletheworld Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit elgaberino's Xanga Site!

@petitenoirtenue - Hurrah!

@skittlesruletheworld - *blushes deeply* What can I say, I have friends who push me along. I am genuinely curious to see what you include on your list.

Posted 1/11/2010 7:19 PM by elgaberino Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit tenshii_rage's Xanga Site!

@elgaberino - 



I think he's a cute little thing, and its sorta cool he was discovered on youtube, but I'm not a huge fan. I just wanted to be sarcastic, but that emotion is difficult to convey over words on a screen.
Posted 1/11/2010 7:30 PM by tenshii_rage Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit Drakonskyr's Xanga Site!
Black Keys - Rubber Factory may literally be the best album of the whole past ten years.
Posted 1/11/2010 7:33 PM by Drakonskyr Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit xXbUbBlEwRaPXx's Xanga Site!

@elgaberino - 

hahaha no I just meant that I think that album belongs in the top ten
Posted 1/11/2010 8:11 PM by xXbUbBlEwRaPXx Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit vanedave's Xanga Site!

@trunthepaige - I was like the first or second to rec! lol.

Posted 1/11/2010 8:15 PM by vanedave Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit anaraug's Xanga Site!
"The Best" and "My Favorite" are very different for me. I have a well-defined idea of what I consider the best of the 90s, but it'll probably take me another 10 years to decide what the best of the 00s were.

So I'll just post my favorites instead. Sometime.
Posted 1/11/2010 9:01 PM by anaraug Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

browse comments: next › | last »


Sign in to CommentChoose Identity
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)

(?)

Back to elgaberino's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in elgaberino's local time zone:
GMT -08:00 (Pacific Standard - US, Canada)